Comparing Property Taxes: Florida vs. New York

Property tax, a mainstay of American local government, is an important aspect of homeownership that often factors into the ongoing cost of owning property. While property tax rates vary significantly from state to state, understanding how they are calculated and their contribution to local and state economies can provide insight into their real-world implications. This article will delve into the intricacies of property tax, further narrowing down to a comparative analysis of the property tax landscape in two unique states– Florida and New York. By examining the specific nuances of their assessment procedures, exemptions, and rates, the article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of how these two states navigate this crucial aspect of governance.

Understanding Property Tax

Understanding Property Tax: Basics and Calculation Methods

Property tax is a key component of government revenue in the U.S., imposed by states, counties and local municipalities. It serves as a primary source of funds to support a range of public services like schools, roads, parks, and emergency services among others. It is figured as a percentage of a property’s assessed value.

Assessment and calculation of property tax can sometimes get complicated as it’s often determined by a property’s assessed value and the tax rate within a particular jurisdiction. The assessed value of a property is usually calculated based on recent sales of similar properties within the area. Counties and municipalities then apply their tax rate, known as mill rate, to the assessed value. Seeing property tax in the context of Florida vs New York can help elucidate many of these elements.

Florida Property Tax

Florida property tax rates are relatively low compared to other states. The average property tax rate for residential property in the state is about 0.83% as of 2021, less than the national average of roughly 1.07%. This means that a home worth $250,000 would, on average, have about $2,075 in annual property tax in Florida.

It is also significant to note that Florida has a homestead exemption that can decrease a property’s taxable value by as much as $50,000 in some cases, providing considerable savings for homeowners. Florida exempts a certain amount of a home’s value from property taxes entirely, so the effective rate is often significantly lower.

New York Property Tax

On the contrary, New York property taxes are considerably higher. The state has one of the highest property tax rates in the U.S., with an average of about 1.69% as of 2021. For the same home valued at $250,000, annual property tax would average about $4,225 in New York.

New York does offer a STAR (School Tax Relief) program that provides property tax relief to eligible homeowners. However, it is more complex and less significant compared to Florida’s homestead exemption.

Impact of Property Tax

Property tax directly affects homeowners since it constitutes a significant portion of their annual expenses, putting a heavier burden on homeowners in high-tax states like New York. At the community level, because property tax is primarily used to fund local efforts, areas with high property taxes can often provide more and better public services, like schools and parks, compared to areas with lower taxes.

At a macroeconomic level, property tax can influence housing markets. High property taxes can make property ownership less attractive and can potentially suppress property values. Similarly, low property tax rates might stimulate housing markets by making home ownership more affordable. This dynamic is clearly observable when comparing real estate markets in Florida and New York.

Wrapping Up

Becoming a homeowner means getting familiar with some important aspects like property tax, and it’s crucial to remember that these provisions, in terms of rates and homestead exemptions, are subject to change. They are dictated by decisions made on a local government level in response to shifting market conditions. For homeowners, it is imperative to stay abreast of such changes as these could impact their property tax payment in the future.

Property Tax in Florida

An Insight into Florida Property Tax

The specifics of property tax in Florida, which are managed by local governments, are determined by the assessed value of the property. To calculate this tax, Florida applies a mill rate, a common practice among many states. For every $1000 of property value, a mill translates to $1 in tax. So, for a house assessed at $250,000 and a mill rate of 20, the owner would be taxed $5,000.

Each year, properties are appraised and around August, homeowners receive their TRIM (Truth in Millage) notices or notifications for proposed property taxes. These TRIM notices share details about the assessed value of the property, exemptions, suggested millage rates, and an estimate of the due taxes.

Florida Homestead Exemption

One key feature of Florida’s property tax system is the homestead exemption. Under this provision, the first $50,000 of the value of a person’s primary residence is exempt from property tax. This is further enhanced by the Save Our Homes provision, which caps the annual increase in assessed value at 3% for properties receiving the homestead exemption.

New York Property Tax: An Overview

In contrast to Florida, New York property tax rates vary greatly by city and county. New York does not utilize a mill rate system. Instead, the amount owners pay in property tax is determined by the assessed value of their property and the tax rate set by their local government.

Property in New York is revalued every year, but actual valuation only occurs when a property is sold or improvements are made. New York property tax also includes school tax, which is a significant part of the property tax bill for many New Yorkers.

New York STAR Exemption

New York offers the School Tax Relief (STAR) program, which reduces school property taxes for eligible homeowners. The exemption applies to owner-occupied, primary residences where the resident owners’ and their spouses’ incomes total less than $500,000. There are two parts to the STAR program: the Basic STAR and the Enhanced STAR for seniors who earn below a certain threshold.

A Comparative Look at Property Taxes in Florida and New York

Florida and New York present notable contrasts when it comes to their property tax systems. Typically, Florida has a lower property tax rate, averaging around 0.83% statewide, compared to New York’s higher 1.68% average. Florida’s lower rates can be partly attributed to their homestead exemption and the rate increase limit set by the Save Our Homes provision.

However, it’s essential to consider that property values in Florida are typically lower than in New York, especially in metropolitan areas. Consequently, property tax payments in both states may align more closely than initially suspected due to the differing property values, despite the noticeable tax rate disparity.

Homeowners in both regions receive tax relief via myriad exemptions. Florida notably offers substantial savings through its homestead exemption while New York’s School Tax Relief (STAR) program aids homeowners in managing school taxes, albeit with income restrictions.

The overseeing and administering bodies for property tax also differ. In Florida, property tax regulation falls under county governance. Conversely, in New York, individual cities and municipalities exert greater control over the property tax policy.

Property Tax in New York

Delving Deeper: An Overview of New York’s Property Tax

New York’s property tax rates are among the nation’s highest, with homeowners generally paying 1.68% of their home value, exceeding the national average of 1.07%. However, it’s important to recognize the wide variance in property tax rates across New York. As per the New York Department of Taxation and Finance, there’s no set property tax rate for the entire state. Instead, the tax rate is determined by each local government—town, city, county, village, or school district—based on total amount required for services, divided by the total taxable assessed value within the respective jurisdiction.

Assessment and Payment of New York Property Taxes

In New York State, the property tax is a local tax, raised and used locally. Property assessment is the basis for determining the property tax, and it’s up to the local assessor to estimate the market value of every property in their community. Once the assessment has been completed, the town, city, or village tax collector sends out bills to homeowners.

Exemptions in New York Property Taxes

Exemptions help reduce homeowners’ tax burden in New York. Certain categories of people can apply for a reduction in their property’s assessed value, such as senior citizens, veterans, and people with disabilities. However, the specifics may vary in each jurisdiction.

New York City Property Tax

New York City, with its costly real estate, has notoriously high property tax bills. However, its property tax rate is much lower than the state average, currently standing at 0.88% of the property’s assessed value. Owing to the high property values in the city, the overall tax burden on property owners in NYC can still turn out to be significant.

Comparison to Florida Property Tax

In terms of average effective property tax rates, Florida has a much more favorable environment than New York. Floridian homeowners pay a rate of 0.98%, lower than the national average, making it one of the lower-tax states in the U.S. However, property tax isn’t the only financial factor to consider when buying a property; although property taxes are lower, insurance rates, especially in coastal areas, are high in Florida.

Florida Property Tax Assessment and Exemptions

Like New York, property taxes in Florida are assessed and collected on a local level. A county property appraiser assesses property values, and then each local government sets a millage rate, which is the amount per $1,000 of property value that is used to calculate taxes. Florida also provides numerous exemptions there is a homestead exemption available to all Florida residents that helps to significantly reduce tax liabilities.


On comparing, each state has its advantages and disadvantages. While Florida’s lower property tax rate may initially appear more attractive, one has to consider factors beyond property taxation. Insurance rates, cost of living, overall tax implications should all be considered when deciding between the two states. Remember that taxation policies and rates can change, and it’s important to do your research or consult with a taxation professional before making a decision.

From the sunny beaches of Florida to the bustling streets of New York, property tax plays a pivotal role in shaping the economic realities for homeowners within these two states. While Florida’s homestead exemption offers considerable benefits for permanent residents, New York’s tax rates present a drastically different scenario that changes significantly across urban and rural landscapes. Understanding these differences not just aids in making informed decisions pertaining to property ownership, but also contributes to our comprehension of the broader economic ecosystems created by such taxes. As such, the complexities of property tax– though often daunting– hold substantial significance in our lives as homeowners and members of our local and state communities.

Leave a Comment